‘Twas two nights before Christmas,
When all through the state Not a person was stirring,
Be it LGBT or straight.
Then Equality Maryland said
That its PAC made some choices,
From governor to delegates,
That led to raised voices.
Many were surprised
That their top pick was Brown,Bringing Gansler and Mizeur folks
A Christmastime frown.
Choosing the front runner
Is easy to handle,But is dividing the community
Worth such a gamble?
The Equality Maryland Political
Action Committee raised some eyebrows with the first round of endorsements for
37 races in Maryland’s 2014 primary elections to take place in June. Their revelation
that the PAC chose the Brown-Ulman ticket caused pre-Christmas stirring from
Takoma Park to Baltimore and all around the state, garnering much media
attention.
The announcement, which occurred just
days before a scheduled January 4 fundraiser for the Brown-Ulman ticket at the
City Café in Baltimore which Carrie Evans, executive director of Equality Maryland is among
the hosts, elicited swift and sharp reaction on social media. Not to be overlooked by the gubernatorial choice is the mystifying fact that none of the lesbians in the House of Delegates were endorsed in this round. They include Maggie McIntosh who finished in second place as the Baltimore Sun’s Marylander of the Year in 2012, Mary Washington, Bonnie Cullison and Anne Kaiser.
“Equality Maryland just lost their last shred of credibility,” commented a transgender rights advocate from Baltimore kicking off a spirited discussion on Facebook.
But at the moment, the endorsement
for governor is creating the most buzz. Although Attorney General Doug Gansler has a
strong LGBT following given his record on marriage equality—a core factor in the
PAC’s evaluation that consisted of questionnaires and interviews—many support
Del. Heather Mizeur’s quest to be the first woman and openly gay person to be
governor of Maryland. Others see Lt. Governor Anthony Brown as the only viable
candidate who could defeat a Republican in November.
“We’ve
made great progress over the past seven years, achieving marriage equality and
strengthening domestic violence services for LGBT residents, while working to
ban discrimination based on gender identity,” Brown said in a statement.
For her part, Mizeur characterized
the choice as “puzzling.” She said, “No one in this race has done more for the LGBT community
than the Mizeur-Coates ticket. I’m not sure what more we could have done to
earn their support.”
Bob Wheelock, a spokesman for
Gansler wrote in an email, “We are confident that Doug’s record on fighting for
and protecting the rights and safety of the LGBT residents of Maryland will
factor into the voters’ decision in the Democratic primary and on Election Day.”
“I
suppose any candidate that doesn’t get an endorsement feels snubbed,” said
Evans. “Equality Maryland is confident the Brown/Ulman administration will
provide the leadership Equality Maryland needs in our next governor and has the
relationships we need to move LGBT issues forward in our state.”
All
three Democratic candidates and their running mates have solid records on LGBT
issues, and to say one is better than the others is questionable. Gansler was the first statewide official to
endorse marriage equality in 2008 and had been an unwavering supporter. His opinion in 2010 as Attorney General that
Maryland can recognize the lawful same-sex marriages from other states helped
pave the way for the ultimate victory in 2012.
Heather
Mizeur, a lesbian with a wife, has also been a vigorous proponent of marriage
equality. I testified along with her at
a House committee hearing for a bill that was aimed at pre-empting Gansler’s eventual
opinion. Mizeur’s testimony was sincere,
persuasive and effective, and one could see great potential for her.
While
I had met Anthony Brown, I never had the opportunity to speak with him on LGBT
issues. Nonetheless, a very credible
source told me that Brown was an early supporter of marriage equality—even before
Governor O’Malley—but worked behind the scenes especially in Prince George’s
County to help make it happen. In
addition, Brown had been a vocal advocate for the repeal of the “Don’t Ask, Don’t
Tell” policy and appeared on national television in that regard.
With all three candidates
possessing strong credentials and leadership, Equality Maryland chose to ride
the perceived front runner. Brown
has racked up most of the endorsements so far, has a formidable war chest and
the backing of the Democratic establishment.
Early polls indicate Brown with a robust lead over the other candidates.
By backing Brown, should he
prevail, Equality Maryland could stand to receive at a minimum access to the O’Malley-Brown
mammoth donor list to help finance the organization as it evolves to a
post-marriage equality mission that will entail a broader scope.
However, the primary is six months
away and much can happen in that timeframe.
Brown’s success (or failure) will undoubtedly be linked to O’Malley’s
popularity, which is often volatile.
Moreover, should he win the nomination, the actual election is by no
means a lock (see above re: O’Malley).
It is indeed a gamble for Equality
Maryland, but is it a good one? The front
running horse may have the probability of a win but it also yields the smallest
payoff. Preferring one candidate now over
two with strong LGBT pedigree, Equality Maryland stands to alienate a significant
number of Gansler and Mizeur supporters—many of whom live in cash-rich Montgomery County
and have been a major source of contributions to the organization over the
years.
Equality Maryland should have
taken a safer course and remained neutral through the primary and not risk
dividing the LGBT community. It would also be better served if it channeled its
energy and whatever resources it possesses towards finding and funding
candidates to defeat anti-LGBT Democratic legislators. Sen. Anthony Muse who has blocked progress
for LGBT folks comes to mind.
Equality Maryland’s PAC rolled the
dice with Anthony Brown and will reap the benefits of this action or pay a
steep price. Time will tell. But like all gambling activities, it’s always
about money.