Featured Post

Four Decades Along the Rainbow Road

Friday, November 20, 2026

‘White Christmas’ Serves Up Pure Holiday Joy at Toby’s

The Company
The evening chill is in the air, Christmas decorations in stores are proliferating, X-mas trees are being bought, and that can only mean the holidays are fast approaching. Nothing warms the soul as a good old-fashioned Christmas musical. And if you want a warm mug of theatrical nostalgia packed with show-stopping tap numbers and timeless melodies, Irving Berlin’s White Christmas delivers pure holiday joy at Toby’s the Dinner Theatre of Columbia.

Under the precise direction of Helen Hayes Award winner Mark Minnick, stunning choreography by Christen Svingos, wonderful musical direction by Ross Scott Rawlings and his fantastic 6-piece orchestra, and an abundantly talented cast, this production of White Christmas is a magical, big-hearted theatrical spectacle.

The musical stage production is based on the beloved 1954 movie of the same title that starred Bing Crosby and Danny Kaye as well as Rosemary Clooney and Vera-Ellen. This stage version by David Ives and Paul Blake polishes the original story into a fast-paced, family-friendly celebration of show business and camaraderie featuring the musical and lyrical genius of Irving Berlin.

Mounting any musical on the tight circular stage of Toby’s is a daunting challenge. But just like so many other musicals in Toby’s 47 year-long and distinguished history, this production of White Christmas meets that bar and then some.

The staging is magnificent, efficiently using all levels and floor space. Production Stage Manager Cheryl Stansfield keeps the action flowing at a flawless pace. That and the vivid lighting design by Lynn Joslin allows the show to play large and makes the viewing that much more pleasurable. And Mark Smedley’s solid sound design enhances the performances.

It didn’t hurt that the opening number was that Christmastime standard “Happy Holiday”—popularized by Bing Crosby and Andy Williams—that has you humming from the get-go.

Though set in the 1950s, the music and choreography feel timeless and upbeat.

Janine Sunday as Betty and Rachel Cahoon as Judy
The story opens in 1944, with GIs Bob Wallace and Phil Davis (played by Toby’s sterling veteran team of Jeffrey Shankle and David James, respectively) singing “White Christmas” to cheer up troops in war-shattered Europe. Ten years later, the duo has become a hit song-and-dance act, kicking off the post-war storyline with a lively rendition of "Happy Holiday/Let Yourself Go" on The Ed Sullivan Show. (Notably, Shankle, James, Janine Sunday, Jane C. Boyle, and Robert Biedermann are all reprising their roles from previous Toby’s productions.)

From there, skirt-chasing Phil and his more cautious buddy Bob pursue another singing duo, the Haines sisters—Judy (Rachel Cahoon) and Betty (Janine Sunday). A mix-up lands the quartet on a train to Pine Tree, Vermont, where they discover the Columbia Inn, owned by the guys’ former Army commander, General Henry Waverly (Robert Biedermann), is facing financial ruin due to a lack of snow. Naturally, they band together to stage a massive musical extravaganza to save the lodge, navigating romantic misunderstandings and plenty of zaniness along the way.

"White Christmas is a magical, big-hearted theatrical spectacle."

Packed with nostalgic standards like “Count Your Blessings Instead of Sheep” and “How Deep is the Ocean,” the story builds to an emotional, snow-dusted finale as the entire company—and audience—join in on “White Christmas” and “I’ve Got My Love to Keep Me Warm.”

Jeffrey Shankle as Bob Wallace is fabulous as usual. He showcases his brilliant, pitch-perfect tenor voice and solid acting chops, which he carries out with flair. He convincingly conveys Bob’s shyness towards Betty during their up and down courtship.

Mr. Shankle is the featured singer in much of the show’s numbers with “Count Your Blessings Instead of Sheep,” “Sisters,” “How Deep is the Ocean” and “The Old Man” being highlights. And when he and the superb Ensemble perform “Blue Skies” with its spin moves and kicks to close out the first act, it is one of the high points in the show.

Jeffrey Shankle as Bob and David James as Phil
Another Toby’s veteran is Helen Hayes winner David James adroitly playing Phil Davis. Demonstrating fine singing and dancing performances, he also throws in well-timed, clever quips. In a duet with Rachel Cahoon as Judy in “The Best Things Happen While You’re Dancing,” Mr. James, as he always does, shines brightly. “Happy Holiday/Let Yourself Go” featuring Mr. Shankle, Mr. James and the Ensemble is a treat.

Both Janine Sunday and Rachel Cahoon as the Haines sisters are terrific and play off the male leads with precision and perfect timing. As the strong-willed and independent Betty, Ms. Sunday is on top of her game with absolutely brilliant vocals. For instance, her duet with Mr. Shankle in the reprise of “How Deep is the Ocean” is stunning.

As the charming and lovely Judy, Ms. Cahoon is ideal for the role, who can also sing with the best of them. Her duet with Ms. Sunday in “Sisters” is superb. Mr. James and Ms. Cahoon are graceful in the gorgeous number with the fitting title, “The Best Things Happen While You’re Dancing.”

Jane C. Boyle, as Martha Waton, the inn’s boisterous and outspoken concierge, is sensational; she never misses a beat.  Possessing comedic timing and a powerful stage presence, Ms. Boyle provides the show an added punch. Sharp, wisecracking and candid, her exchanges with General Waverly bring laughs. Her solo rendition of “Let Me Sing and I’m Happy” truly hits the mark and performs well in combined numbers.

Another standout is veteran actor Robert Biedermann who plays General Henry Waverly to a tee. Though retired, he still longs to return to the Army as he struggles with running the inn and adapting to retirement.  Brusk but loveable, the General had fallen under hard economic times with his inn. Mr. Biedermann conveys this situation movingly so that the audience finds it easy to root for him.

Then there is young Susie, the General’s devoted granddaughter played by Julia Ballenger the evening of this reviewed presentation. (Lily Martin or Ellie May Sennett play the part in other performances.)

On this night, Julia sparkled playing the feisty, loveable youngster who had her moment in the spotlight with a gorgeous rendition of the reprise of “Let Me Sing and I’m Happy.” This song is intended to convince the Christmas show’s organizers at the inn that she can perform.

Other notable performances are turned in by Zachary Spafford as the animated and spirited TV Announcer and frenetic Christmas Show Director; and Jordan B. Stocksdale as Ralph Sheldrake, the former Army buddy of Bob and Phil and now executive; and Shawn Kettering, who plays multiple comedic roles.

The Ensemble displays its dancing prowess throughout the show. They include
The Company performing "I Love a Piano"

Brandon Bedore, MaryKate Brouillet, Helen Hayes winner Joey Ellinghaus, Jaylen Fontaine, Helen Hayes nominee Nicky Kaider, Amanda Kaplan-Landstrom, Alexis Krey-Bedore, Emily Signor and Patricia “Pep” Targete.

Dance is a huge component of White Christmas. This company hoofs it up skillfully with lots of energy and graceful movement to the tuneful songs. Credit Choreographer Christen Svingos for effectively designing the playbook, allowing the dancers to show off their talents on a tight stage.

But the show-stopper is the rousing second act opener “I Love a Piano” that features a scintillating display of tap-dancing talent by the Ensemble, reflecting extraordinary choreography by Ms. Svingos.  Being in the round, you feel the vibrations through the floor and see every ounce of the cast’s athleticism from every angle.

Scenic Designer Shane Lowry employs clever scenery and set pieces to add heft to the production. He mounted wood panels on the theater’s walls to depict the barn’s interior. Some Christmas wreaths and evergreen boughs around the theater provide the right feel. Such varied scenes include the inn, a train ride, a ballroom, a TV studio among others. The best is the lobby of the inn with a front desk and a neatly decorated staircase leading to the inn’s rooms.

In addition to her leading role in the show, Janine Sunday is also the Costume Designer along with Sarah King. Well over a hundred pieces of wardrobe are employed that ranged from period formal gowns to Army uniforms and much in between. The costumes are a significant element in the show’s visual appeal. And hats off to Hair/Wig designer Jayson Kueberth for his outstanding work.

Irving Berlin’s White Christmas at Toby’s, a snow globe filled with artistry, is unapologetically sentimental, visually lush, and brimming with talent. Its sincerity and gentle humor hit the seasonal sweet spot. 

The combination of a superb cast, rich orchestral arrangements, dazzling costumes, and infectious tap-dancing makes it an ideal holiday outing for families of all kinds. 

It is the present you may be looking for.

Advisory: Smoke, haze and fog effects are used in the show.

Running time. Two hours and 35 minutes with an intermission.

White Christmas plays through January 10, 2027, at Toby’s the Dinner Theatre, 4900 Symphony Woods Rd., Columbia, MD 21044.  Tickets may be purchased by calling the box office at 410-730-8311 or visiting online. 

Photos: Jeri Tidwell Photography

The menu for the outstanding buffet is shown here.

Specialty Drink: The Million-Dollar Proposition

Next Up: Grease opens January 15, 2027, the final presentation at the current theater. On April 3, 2027, Crazy For You will launch the brand-new theater.

No comments: