![]() |
Ashley D. Nguyen (Dawn), Malinda (Jenna), and Allison Blackwell (Jenna) |
It is hard to imagine that themes, such as an unwanted pregnancy, an abusive husband, adultery, and sexual encounters in the workplace would keep you laughing until your eyes tear, but here we are with Waitress. To be sure, the instances when these themes are addressed are also handled tenderly and with great emotion. The mixture is effective.
Olney Theatre Center’s production of the musical Waitress in the Roberts Mainstage reunites star Malinda in the lead role of Jenna, and director/choreographer Marcia Milgrom Dodge. Waitress is a high-energy, often hilarious, and at times poignant presentation with all elements clicking. Excellent staging, an ultra-talented cast, a wonderful score, great sets, costumes and lighting make up all slices of the tasty pie.
Malinda (formerly known as Malinda Kathleen Reese; she now goes by the mononym used in her singing career) won the 2020 Helen Hayes Award for Outstanding Performance in a Musical for her last turn at Olney Theatre as the Girl in Once.
Waitress may not be the most well-known musical to ever hit the stage but it is a first-rate one. It garnered four Tony Award nominations in 2016 including Best Musical. The all-female creative team includes music and lyrics by Sara Bareilles and a book by Jessie Nelson. It is based on the 2007 film of the same name, written by Adrienne Shelly.
Accordingly, there is a palpable amount of feminism laced throughout as the story deals with the veracity of the lives of working women in America and how women bond to help bring out the best in each.
The multi-layered plot centers on Jenna, a baker and waitress at Joe’s Pie Diner in a small Southern town. She has a penchant for creating magnificent pies and coming up with clever names for them based on the situation. Many of her recipes originated with her late mother but Jenna concocts some pies on the fly. There are pies galore in this show, and thankfully, they are not the kind seen in Sweeney Todd.
Her problem is that she is in loveless relationship with her
temper-prone husband Earl (played by Greg
Twomey) who is abusive and demanding.
As an example, he regularly pops in the diner and collects the tips she earned while he habitually shows up
late for work and is constantly on the precipice of being fired.
You would think Jenna would have left him given this toxic relationship. Easy as pie? Not so fast. Complicating matters is that Jenna discovered she was unexpectedly pregnant as a result of a drunken night with Earl—a development in which she kept from him until she blurted it out right before he attempted to strike her.
Jenna attempts to escape from this misery by finding solace in baking pies and also from the companionship of her two close friends in the diner, waitresses Becky (Allison Blackwell) and Dawn (Ashley D. Nguyen.) The trio serves as confidants to one another and provides the moral support needed to escape from their ho-hum existence and to make choices to seek the joy that had been missing from their lives. Each reveals their own bit of eccentricities as they embark on this journey.
![]() |
Sam C. Jones (Ogie), Malinda (Jenna) and Ashley D. Nguyen (Dawn) |
Jenna’s baking prowess leads her to consider entering a pie baking contest that would award $20,000 to the winner and enable her to leave Earl.
Adding another element to the plot is that Jenna has fallen for her handsome gynecologist, Dr. Jim Pomatter (David Socolar), who as it turns out, is also married, and the two have sex in his office. That makes for a zesty and hilarious scene. Mr. Socolar’s athleticism, physical comedy and his fumbling of a piece of paper in that office is one of the show’s highlights.
Meanwhile, Becky, also married, begins an affair with Cal (Ethan Watermeier), a manager at the diner, and Dawn finds love from an uproariously gawky goofball, Ogie, (Sam C. Jones), she met online.
So, there you go. The ingredients for this pie of a plot are in place. It’s just a matter of how they are mixed and with the right proportions to make it yummy. Spoiler alert: it is scrumptious!
Ms. Bareilles’ ballad-heavy score is solid with many numbers heart-wrenching and tender, such as the exraordinary “She Used to Be Mine” and “Take it From an Old Man.” Some are simply playful and much fun like “Never Ever Getting Rid of Me.” The show starts off on the right foot with the snappy number “What’s Inside.”
As the central character Jenna, Malinda excels on all fronts. Her acting is strong in portraying the victim trapped in her marriage and the anguish she experiences in confronting the reality of her pregnancy as well as her dealing with infidelity. Malinda’s soprano voice is crystal clear and powerful, holding notes exceptionally. Her solos “What Baking Can Do” and the show-stopping “She Used to Be Mine” showcase her vocal prowess.
"Excellent staging, an ultra-talented cast, a wonderful score, great sets, costumes and lighting make up all slices of the tasty pie."
Allison Blackwell as Becky, one of the waitresses, fills the comedy role with relish. Sassy and loud, Ms. Blackwell demonstrates impeccable comedic timing with her wisecracking antics directed mainly towards her boss Cal (played effectively by Ethan Watermeier). Always on the edge of being fired by Cal, Becky intimidates him enough to stay on and has an affair with Cal though she, too, is in an unfulfilling marriage. Ms. Blackwell joins other cast members in song but her one solo number “I Didn’t Plan It” soars.
The third waitress in the musical is Dawn played wonderfully by Ashley D. Nguyen. A shy, quirky type, Dawn is another who plays a largely comedic role. Through online dating, she meets a guy named Ogie (played terrifically by Sam C. Jones). Initially, it was hate at first sight from Dawn’s perspective, but once they found out both loved American Revolution re-enactments, it was just a matter of time that they would marry.
Mr. Jones’ Ogie is a scene stealer with his nerdy looks and his physical comedy offerings. He sang in "I Love You Like a Table,” but his performance with Ms. Nguyen in the production number “Never Ever Getting Rid of Me” where he briefly shows off his odd dance moves and his own brand of athleticism is a genuine showstopper.
David Socolar as the gynecologist Dr. Pomatter is one of the show’s standouts. Nimble physically with astounding comedic timing, Mr. Socolar turns in a superb performance as his character navigates the tricky terrain of adultery while he falls deeply for his patient Jenna. There were many funny lines, and he executed them to perfection. Mr. Socolar performs splendidly with Malinda in “It Only Takes a Taste,” “Bad Idea” and the tender ballad You Matter to Me” –also a duet with Malinda—displaying a smooth tenor voice.
Then there is the villain of the show, Earl, Jenna’s arrogant and manipulative husband, played convincingly by Greg Twomey. His sweet duet with Malinda in “You Will Still Be Mine” follows his request that Jenna will not love the baby more than him. He has accomplished vocal skills.
Bobby Smith as Joe, the aging, cranky, picky and generous owner of Joe’s Pie Diner, is excellent in his role that calls on him to be comedic and gruff and eventually gentle and kindhearted. He is a fan of Jenna and encourages her to participate in the pie contest. Mr. Smith’s performance in the lovely ballad, “Take it From an Old Man,” is touching. The surprise ending involving Joe is a game changer on several levels.
Rounding out the excellent cast is Jessica Bennett who deliciously plays Nurse Norma. She is wise to Dr. Pomatter’s antics and is hilarious with her reactions.
The talented Ensemble support the leads with solid vocal back-up and occasional dancing. Also, providing a musical lift is the 7 –piece on-stage orchestra conducted splendidly by Christopher Youstra.
Scenic Designer Chen-Wei Liao created a wonderfully functional set. Much of the action takes place in the diner with its kitchen, tables, counter and other props that depict the small town eatery. Other scenes switch seamlessly to the doctor’s office, Jenna and Earl’s home among other venues by utilizing two covered rectangular openings on the stage where set pieces rise up an elevator.
Minjoo Kim’s lighting design is bright and cheery that adds quality to the production. And Sarah Cubbage added more flavor to the pie with terrific and imaginative costumes.
Waitress is a well-staged and well-directed musical with a wonderful score that takes on serious issues with a good heart and levity. The performers excel in all facets, and the show makes for a most entertaining experience, no matter how you slice it.
Advisory: The show contains mature themes and sexual situations and is not recommended for young children.
Running time. Two hours and 45 minutes with an intermission.
Waitress runs through April 6 in the Roberts Mainstage at Olney Theatre Center, 2001 Olney-Sandy Spring Road, Olney, MD. Tickets ($41-$116) are available online or through the box office at 301-924-3400, open from 12 p.m. – 6 p.m. Wednesdays through Saturdays.
Performance Schedule
Wednesday through Saturday evenings at 7:30 p.m.
Wednesday, Saturday, and Sunday matinees at 1:30 p.m.
Select Sunday evenings at 7:00 p.m.
See the full schedule at: https://tickets.olneytheatre.org/overview/waitress
Accessible Performances Audio-Described Performance – Wednesday, March 5 at 7:30p.m.
ASL Interpreted Performance – Thursday, March 6 at 7:30 p.m.
Due to popular
demand, Waitress has been extended from
March 30 to April 6.
The additional performance schedule is as follows:
Thursday, April 3 at 7:30 p.m.
Friday, April 4 at 1:30 p.m.
Friday, April 4 at 7:30 p.m.
Saturday, April 5 at 1:30 p.m.
Saturday, April 5 at 7:30 p.m.
Sunday, April 6 at 1:30 p.m.