Featured Post

Four Decades Along the Rainbow Road

Friday, June 26, 2026

‘Mean Girls’ Learn to Play Nice at Toby’s

I’m so far removed from high school it was only called school back in the day, and the third side of a triangle in Geometry hadn’t been discovered. There was no TikTok, Instagram or smartphones. If you wanted to talk behind someone’s back, you simply talked behind someone’s back.

It’s different today, and any meanness can be fueled by social media and even a “burn book.” This phenomenon is displayed in the rousing musical Mean Girls currently playing at Toby’s, the Dinner Theatre of Columbia.

Though it’s a challenge for me to relate to the modern-day high school culture, I enjoyed the musical Mean Girls.  Helen Hayes Award winner Mark Minnick directed the talented cast through a well-staged, high-energy production with superb attention to details. David Singleton choreographed the dance-heavy musical with precision and creativity mimicking the chaos of high school vitality. The vocals by the performers as well as the high-voltage dancing executed by the entire cast are stellar contributing to a polished production. 

Mean Girls, based on the 2004 film of the same name, entertains on all fronts. The artistic cast and the six-piece orchestra directed by Ross Scott Rawlings deliver the music by Jeff Richmond, the clever lyrics by Nell Benjamin, and a book by Tina Fey of TV fame who also wrote the film.

Richmond’s and Benjamin’s music, while not spectacular, works well in bringing the story along. Several songs are notable and spread throughout the cast so that all the leads have a turn. The lyrics feature a decent degree of wit, but Fey’s droll and biting dialogue carries the day.

Conveyed in a contemporary universe where social media can make or break someone, the plot is punchy and at times, preachy. But it is melded into a hilarious tale focusing on teenagers’ social angst and its related mission to strive for popularity seemingly at all costs.

Tobi Baisburd as Janis and Alan Gutierrez-Urista as Damian

The central character Cady Heron (played spectacularly by Rachel Cahoon) is invited into The Plastics—a three-girl clique of high schoolers.  She is there to not only spy on the group as directed by her new friend Janis Sarkisian (Tobi Baisburd) who has vengeance on her mind towards the “queen bee” Regina George (MaryKate Brouillet), but also to boost her social status and desirability. As one of the lead characters Damian Hubbard (Alan Gutierrez-Urista) aptly put it, The Plastics are called that because “they are shiny, fake and hard.”  How that relationship works out for all concerned forms the crux of the story.

Cady had moved to a Chicago suburb from Kenya where her biologist parents had home schooled her. Naïve Cady realizes that she was not even noticed let alone accepted by the kids at North Shore High School until Janis and Damian Hubbard befriend her. This duo also act as the show’s narrators breaking the 4th wall.

In the school cafeteria they point out to Cady the school’s eclectic cliques—jocks, nerds, sex maniacs, freaks among others—and then ultimately describe The Plastics—Regina George (MaryKate Brouillet), the leader; Gretchen Wieners (Emily Flack), the second in command; and Karen Smith (Alexis Krey Bedore), not the smartest phone in the pocket.

Janis had an unpleasant history with Regina, and as a means to revenge, she encouraged Cady to accept The Plastics’ invitation to sit with them for a week in the cafeteria in order to spy on them and feed Janis with information she can use against Regina.

As the members of The Plastics revealed their own individual personalities and character, Cady using cattiness and mean tricks maneuvered to eventually oust Regina as the number one Plastic and emerge as a popular force in the school.


Along the way, she became smitten with a talented and good-looking math student Aaron Samuels (Payton O’Keefe) who liked the more innocent version of Cady as opposed to what she later became.

The Plastics had compiled a “burn book” whereby photos of classmates were pasted in with nasty and mean comments included. Totally mean. The revelation of this book provides the turning point in the plot and the road to redemption and forgiveness was paved.

As Cady, Rachel Cahoon is convincing as the once naïve student who rose to the top of the social ladder and ultimately recognizing that hurting people was not the proper means to reach that goal. She is an exceptional math student and had resisted until the end to be part of the Mathletes math team. She had been warned by The Plastics that if she joined such a group, she would experience “social suicide.” Ms. Cahoon’s mezzo-soprano vocals shine in such numbers as “Stupid with Love,” “Apex Predator” and “More is Better.”

Tobi Baisburd as Janis possesses fine acting skills in portraying her complex character. Janis’ relationship with Regina was once friendly until the latter spread rumors that Janice was a lesbian forcing her to drop out of school at one point. Recognizing the ills of The Plastics, she tried to steer Cady away from the group’s influence.

"David Singleton choreographed the dance-heavy musical with precision and creativity mimicking the chaos of high school vitality."

Ms. Baisburd has an amazingly powerful voice, which is evident in several group numbers including “Apex Predator,” “Revenge Party” and the superbly moving “I’d Rather Be Me.”

MaryKate Brouillet is adept in portraying The Plastics’ leader Regina George. Wealthy with a “cool mom” (Valerie Adams Rigsbee), Regina’s cruelty and meanness is evident throughout, and an unlikely and near fatal encounter with a school bus altered her outlook for the better.  

As she engaged in reconciliation with Cady, Regina pointed out that she was “dead” for 15 seconds and offered her spoiler alert that heaven was a large hotel in Miami.

 Ms. Brouillet sings well as she always does in “Someone Gets Hurt” and “World Burn.”

Emily Flack plays the insecure second-in-command Gretchen as a member of The Plastics. Displaying nervous charm and quick wit, she divulges Regina’s secrets to help deal with her insecurity.  Ms. Flack showcases her lovely voice in one of the few solos in the show, the touching “What’s Wrong with Me?”

 In a comedic role Alexis Krey-Bedore performs exceptionally as the third member of The Plastics, Karen Smith. Essentially vapid and dumb, Karen is loveable and easily manipulated. Ms. Krey-Bedore handles the comedic role with impeccable timing and displays her fine vocals in “Sexy.”

Rachel Cahoon as Cady and Payton O'Keefe as Aaron

My favorite character of all is fierce and sassy Damian, who is played brilliantly by Alan Gutierrez-Urista, making his debut at Toby’s. Damian is the only character in the show who seems totally comfortable in his own skin and doesn’t need to pretend to be anybody else. This is both refreshing and surprising that an openly gay high school student is not the target of bullies and seems so together.

Mr. Gutierrez-Urista is blessed to have the lion’s share of the funny quips and carries the comedic role to perfection. He is also a splendid vocalist “Where Do You Belong?” “Revenge Party” and an accomplished dancer in the rousing opening production number of the second act “Mean”. 

Other notable members of the cast include Otega Okurume as Mr. Duvall; Nico Thompson as Kevin G and who is also in the Ensemble; and Brandon Bedore, who ably steps into a variety of roles throughout. The remainder of the stellar Ensemble who sing and dance up a storm are JC Bost, Joey Ellinghaus, Jaylen Fontaine, Amanda Kaplan Landstrom, Kayla Marks, Katelyn O’Connor, Anna Phillips-Brown, Gab Ryan, and Bryan Stopak.

David Singleton’s choreography is one of the show’s best features conforming to the in-the-round stage at Toby’s.  The wonderful dancers bring this chorography to life especially in such numbers as “Sexy,” “Revenge Party,” “Whose House Is This?” and the finale “I See Stars.”

The use of images on the video screens around the theater depict high school scenes like lockers and classrooms, and when equations from a Calculus class appeared, I almost went into cardiac arrest from the memory trauma it produced. Many cool props and set pieces are used to enhance the optics.

Janine Sunday does a fabulous job with a wide array of costumes befitting modern-day high schoolers. Unexpected, to me at least, is a New York Islanders jersey worn by Payton O’Keefe as Aaron Samuels.

And, of course, there were wigs for the female students with Jayson Kueberth doing a fine job in designing them. A full listing of the Production Staff and Orchestra is shown below.

This fast-paced, well-directed production of Mean Girls featuring an extremely talented cast, several of whom are new to Toby’s audiences, exceptional choreography and singing performances makes this a must-see experience and will keep you in the pink. The ultimate message of being kind to one another no matter what era you’re from hits the mark.

And the marvelous buffet will put you in the right mood. Don’t skip Regina's BBQ ribs!

Running time. Two hours and 40 minutes with an intermission.

Mean Girls plays through August 23 at Toby’s the Dinner Theatre, 4900 Symphony Woods Rd., Columbia, MD 21044.  Tickets may be purchased by calling the box office at 410-730-8311or visiting here.

Photos: Jeri Tidwell Photography

The menu is shown here.

Specialty Drink: The Burn Book

Next up: Summer: The Donna Summer Musical August 28 to November 1




  

No comments: